
Kristina Jovanović
You open a few digital-marketing-agency websites and quickly get the same impression: everyone offers strategy, creative solutions and results. The proposals arrive, but it is still not much clearer what you are actually comparing.
Does more posting mean a better collaboration? Do well-known clients in a portfolio mean the agency is the right choice for you as well? And what exactly do you receive for the monthly fee?
Choose an agency by how well it understands your business, who will run it, what the proposal actually covers, and how you will review results. The portfolio and the first impression matter, but the decision should rest on concrete answers.
These seven questions will help you get them.
1. What does the agency want to learn about your business?
A good collaboration begins with questions. Who are your customers? Why do they choose you? Which products or services are the priority? What have you already tried, and where are you losing opportunities today?
A restaurant that wants more weekday reservations and a shop that wants more online sales do not necessarily need the same mix of channels, messaging or budget.
So pay attention to whether the agency is researching your situation, or immediately recommending the same package it offers everyone. A standardised package is not a problem in itself. The problem arises when no one checks whether it fits your needs.
Digital marketing strategy should connect the objective, the audience, the channels and the available budget. You do not need the entire plan for free in the first conversation, but you should understand how the agency will arrive at a proposal.
2. Who will actually work on your project?
The person who presents the agency does not have to be the person who will run your account day to day. That is common, but it is important to know in advance how the work is organised.
Ask who your contact is, who sets the strategy, who delivers the activity and who checks the quality. If external collaborators are involved, clarify who coordinates their work.
A portfolio can attract attention, but a conversation about concrete projects shows more. What was the brief, which part did the agency do, and how did it judge success? If it cites results, ask for the period, the starting point and the scale of investment.
Experience in your industry can be an advantage. Experience with a similar business challenge also matters — a long sales cycle, for example, or connecting an online campaign with visits to a physical location.
3. What exactly is included in the fee?
Two proposals with the same monthly fee can cover entirely different work.
One includes strategy, shooting and content production. The other assumes that you supply the photographs and video. One includes answering messages; the other only publishing.
Before you compare prices, check:
- what is delivered, in what volume and to what deadlines;
- whether the media budget is separate from the agency fee;
- whether shooting, design, copy and revisions are included;
- who supplies the materials and who approves the content;
- what is charged extra, and whether the price includes VAT where applicable.
The lowest fee means little if you later pay extra for activity you cannot do without. Likewise, a larger proposal is not automatically better if it covers services you do not currently need.
4. How will you measure success, and when will you review progress?
Results matter, but not every number answers the same question.
Views show that the content was seen. Clicks show that someone took a next step. Qualified enquiries, bookings and purchases sit closer to a business outcome — but even those should not be read without cost and context.

If the aim is filling appointments, agree in advance what you will track: enquiries, confirmed bookings or completed visits. Also agree how those data will reach the agency.
This distinction also matters when you assess content that works for the algorithm and content that works for the business. Visibility has a role, but it should be clear how it supports your objective.
Ask for a plan of first steps and a date for reviewing progress. The timeline depends on the channel, the starting point, the budget and the sales process. A promise of precise growth without sight of those data should be examined further.
5. What does communication look like once the work begins?
The way someone explains a proposal, listens to questions and respects agreed deadlines is the first indication of the collaboration to come.
Before you start, clarify how often you speak, where you exchange materials, when you receive a report and how changes are approved. Also agree what counts as an urgent request.
A good report should explain what was done, what was observed and what comes next. If you see a drop in results, you should understand what is being checked, and why.
Marketing should not be something that “happens” to you. You should understand enough to take decisions together, even when you do not know every technical term.
6. Who controls the accounts, the data and the materials?
This question is easy to skip while everything looks promising. Ask it before the collaboration begins.
Clarify who controls the domain and hosting, who has administrator access to ad accounts, analytics and business profiles, and what remains available to you if you change agency.
Also check what you receive of the materials: final visuals and video, source files, copy and reports. Rights to photographs, music and other licensed elements can carry particular restrictions, so those should be agreed clearly too.
Finally, read the terms on duration and termination, the notice period and the handover. Clear terms help both sides know where they stand.
7. What happens when results do not appear?
Marketing is not an entirely linear process. Sometimes a message does not attract the expected audience. Sometimes an ad brings interested people, but the site does not lead them clearly to an enquiry. Sometimes the problem appears later, because calls go unanswered.
So ask how the agency identifies where the work is stalling, and how it decides what to change.
A responsible partner explains what the data show, what is still unknown and what the next step is. It takes responsibility for its part of the work, and speaks openly when a change is needed in the offer, the site or an internal process.
It also matters what is expected of you. Without sales information, feedback on enquiries and timely approvals, the agency finds it harder to assess and improve its work.
How to compare proposals and make a decision
Send agencies the same short description of the business, the objective, an indicative budget and the expected start date. Then compare their answers through these seven questions.
If any point is unclear, ask for clarification before you decide. You need to understand what you are buying, who does the work, and how you will check whether the collaboration is heading in the right direction.
The feeling that someone understands you matters. It is worth most when it is accompanied by a clear plan, responsibilities and agreements that both sides can keep.
At Pinpoint we believe every client deserves attention as if they were the only one. That is why, before a proposal, we want to understand your business, your priorities and what you have already tried. You can meet our approach, and the people who lead the agency, on the PinPoint team page.
Looking for an agency, and want to check whether we are a good fit for your business? Book a complimentary consultation. We will talk about your objective, the activity so far and the room to improve. Book a consultation
Written by: Kristina Jovanović · LinkedIn
All articles